Marcus Dowling is at war with culture.
There’s a new issue plaguing the urban underground. There’s just too much of it. Maybe it’s slightly different where you’re from, if it’s New York, Miami or LA, cities that have a large enough population to justify such volumes of supported culture. But for new boom cities that have yet to develop a significant population of support like Washington, DC, it’s starting to get out of control. A culture has come with this new generation, a party culture that is faux hipster and more urban chic than anything, as ironically, kids who 20 years ago would be at big room nightspots are now all about the DIY underground. With the inherent self-celebritiy that has come because of the influx of message boards, then websites and social networking, why support a star when you can be one yourself. This in turn has developed a terrible trend in my mind, the rise of the DJ. Somewhere in this rise lies the downfall of mid-sized urban cities having a thriving underground, as kids with disposable incomes and that aforementioned DIY attitude get to pretend to be Grandmaster Flash, Kenny “Dope” Gonzalez or Larry Levan, and instead of developing their craft, develop a culture of musical apathy that exists only as background noise filler to nightspots instead of advancing an underground musical culture.
DJs break records. DJs set standards. DJs excite lives. DJs create hysteria. DJs don’t excel at keyboard mashing. DJs don’t just play parties. DJs don’t social climb. DJ’s don’t Tweet every weekend about “going in.” In fact, let’s take that one further and imagine a world where DJs didn’t even Tweet, instead like Richie Hawtin, just used Twitter DJ to show the tracks they’re “murking/slaying/defenestrating/shooting full of lead” the crowd with. In removing the art from the form, it dilutes the craft, and is ruining what has been historically the most important part of urban subculture.
With the advent of Serato and Traktor, being a DJ is a fairly simple proposition. With minimal training and maximum downloads from Mediafire and Rapidshare, you can have a filled “crate” of hits that will “move the crowd.” However, at no point did we mention an intrinsic understanding of how to mix, why to mix, and how to create an atmosphere to move a room? No. And often, it doesn’t exist. Yes, there are those who have mastered this art, and, well, those are the ones you see with the big/regular gigs and their name always mentioned, even on this website. Outside of that, go out and listen. Not to disparage anyone learning as there is a learning curve, but when there is a constant and consistent nature of multiple trainwrecks in mixes, a maximum of people buying drinks at the bar, or a general glazed over apathy of the crowd as the norm, maybe it’s time to stop digging and start dancing. But that NEVER happens. Instead, a city like DC books DJs everywhere. Nightclubs, restaurants, bars, wine shops, bookstores, art galleries, clothiers, everywhere. The over-saturation of parties and functions requiring mixed music alongside the rapidly dwindling returns for quality professionals is a terrible combination that will absolutely have long term effects.
There’s a cultural rape at work in the larger mainstream that has trickled to this point. We’ve gone from music aiming to be timeless to music being a trending topic on Twitter for three hours. Then, it becomes ultimately disposable after a mix, then a remix, then another remix, one of which is done by someone eminently credible, the other two done by someone enamored with dubstep for the next, five, four, three, two, onto the next one. These party nights don’t hold the same cache they historically used to. I look at the gleam in people’s eyes when they talk about nights at Studio 54, The Shelter, The Loft or the Paradise Garage. I don’t see that same glow when people discuss Nouveau Riche, the 411 NY Ave Warehouse or the TNT Association Ballroom. And it’s not for lack of trying, it just feels like the craft has been savaged in order to advance a fad.
Music, for some of us like myself, is not a fad. To the promoters putting music anywhere and everywhere and non-quality DJs out there (if you read that phrase and feel a twinge in your chest, that’d mean you), please stop. Just, stop. My favorite venue in the city is the Palace of Wonders on H Street. If I didn’t cover music, I’d be there all the time. They have burlesque. I mean, wow. You just don’t see that every day. If I didn’t sell my soul to basslines forever ago, I’d love to spend a night at Jammin’ Java in Vienna watching a guy play an acoustic guitar. Yes, in a band. Remember those? I dig Matt Hemmerlein’s sound. Hell. Let’s get him some gigs. No DJs, just a guy with a guitar, and maybe some background instruments playing originals and covers. All night. And hell. I love jukeboxes, too. Fuck. Someone wants to play Skynyrd all night and you love Udachi remixes and Passion Pit? It either sucks to be you and you talk to people all night and get wasted (remember that?), or, you find a place where a top tier and credible professional will, hell, play you some Passion Pit, and if you’re lucky, expertly mix in a couple of other new ones you’ve never heard in such a way that you’re a fan, and the underground has done its job.
On Friday night, I watched Will Eastman and Brian Billion spin 90s hits to 1200 people at the “No Scrubs” dance party at the 9:30 Club. 1200. For someone who tracks and charts music and culture as closely as I do, it made me pause and think? Maybe DC just wants to have fun. Maybe DC isn’t about caring about the cultivation of a thriving and meaningful underground anymore. It feels like nobody wants to be Ian Mackaye, but everybody wants to be Ian Ziering. If that’s a broad generalization, then I apologize. Maybe people just don’t care about quality, maybe they just want to dance. Maybe not even dance. Maybe. Maybe. Then in that case play on, everyone. And leave old men with old ideals in the corner. I think this new party train has passed me by, or I have no desire to get on board anymore.